1990s

1990-1991

John Gaskell, President (Through March 1991)
Cait Calvo, President (April-June 1991)

Bye-Bye Birdie – Don Gillis
Close Ties – Cait Calvo
Gypsy – Sheila M. Ribeiro
Never Too Late (Repeat) – Ronn Marshall
Hearts & Flowers (Original – Summer Theater) – Bill Ferrara

1991-1992 

Lawrence D. Reedy, President

Joseph & The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat – Larry Reedy
Diary Of Anne Frank (Repeat) – Bob Mitchell
Bells Are Ringing – Cait Calvo
How The Other Half Loves – Sandy Boyer

1992-1993 

Lawrence D. Reedy, President

The Melody Lingers On (Original) – Bill Ferrara
Rumors – Tony Annicone
Camelot – Larry Reedy
See How They Run – Ronn Marshall

1993-1994 

Victor S. Turenne, President

Sweet Charity – Ed Rondeau
Night Of January 16th (Repeat) – Brian Mulvey
Into The Woods – Sheila Ribeiro
The Odd Couple (Female Version) – Tony Annicone
I Feel A Song Coming On (Original-Summer Theatre) – Bill Ferrara

1994-1995 

Victor S. Turenne, President

Once Upon A Mattress (Repeat) – Ronn Marshall
You Can’t Take It With You (Repeat) – Andrew g. Bobola
Where Were You When The Bombs Fell? (Repeat) – Bill Ferrara
Lost In Yonkers – Cait Calvo

1995-1996 
75th Diamond Jubilee Celebration

Lee A. Hakeem, President

Man Of La Mancha (Repeat) – Larry Reedy
Side-By-Side By Sondheim – Sheila Ribeiro
Godspell (Repeat) – Karen Gail Kessler
The Cemetery Club – Sandy Boyer

1996-1997

Lee A. Hakeem, President

Annie Get Your Gun – Peggy Pires
Ten Little Indians (Repeat) – Ronn Marshall
Baby – Brian Mulvey
Noises Off – Erika Koch
3x3x3 (One Act Showcases)

1997-1998

Peter F. Babiec, President

Nunsense – Don Gillis
Wait Until Dark (Repeat) – Tony Annicone
Mame – Larry Reedy
Steel Magnolias – Andrew G. Bobola

1998-1999

Peter F. Babiec, President

The Heiress – Vincent Lupino
Gifts of the Magi – Carol Varden
3x3x3 – One Act Showcases
They’re Playing Our Song – Karen Gail Kessler
Seven Year Itch – Brian Mulvey

1999-2000 

Lolly Hakeem , President

3x3x3 One Act Showcases
Fiddler On The Roof (Repeat) – Andrew g. Bobola
Musical Comedy Murders of 1940’s – Ronn Marshall
Lend Me A Tenor – Kevin Costa
The Man Who Owned Broadway (Original Revue) – Marcia Zammarelli